Click here and press the right key for the next slide (or swipe left)
also ...
Press the left key to go backwards (or swipe right)
Press n to toggle whether notes are shown (or add '?notes' to the url before the #)
Press m or double tap to slide thumbnails (menu)
Press ? at any time to show the keyboard shortcuts
‘I have been in the habit of misusing the order of nature. For‘the proper purpose of [...] sensory perceptions [...] is simply to inform the mind of what is beneficial or harmful [...];
and to this extent they are sufficiently clear and distinct.
But I misuse them by treating them as reliable touchstones for immediate judgements about the essential nature of the bodies located outside us;
yet this is an area where they provide only very obscure information.’
Descartes, Meditation IV
Sensory perceptions of tastes, smells, sounds, heat, cold, light, colors and the like ‘do not represent anything located outside our thought’
These sensory perceptions ‘vary according to the different movements which pass from all parts of our body to the ... brain’
Principles
‘Something which I thought I was seeing with my eyes is in fact grasped solely by the faculty of judgement which is in my mind’
(Meditation 2).
Is Descartes’ consistent?
Sensory perceptions of tastes, smells, sounds, heat, cold, light, colors and the like ‘do not represent anything located outside our thought’
Principles
‘the proper purpose of [...] sensory perceptions [...] is simply to inform the mind of what is beneficial or harmful’
Sensory perceptions ‘normally tell us of the benefit or harm that external bodies may do [...], and do not, except [...]accidentally, show us what external bodies are like in themselves’
‘pain will be felt as if it were in the foot [...] deception of the senses is natural’
‘[the intellect] must not judge that external things always are just as they appear to be.’ (Rule 12)
Inconsistent tetrad:
1. Sensory perceptions represent things.
2. What can represent can misrepresent.
3. Anything that can misrepresent can be a source of error.
4. Sensory perceptions cannot be a source of error.
External bodies
‘may not exist in a way that
exactly corresponds with my sensory grasp of them,
for in many cases the
grasp of the senses
is very obscure and confused.
But at least they possess all the properties which I clearly and distinctly understand,
that is all those which, viewed in general terms, are comprised within the subject matter of pure mathematics.’
‘the intellect can never be deceived by any experience, provided that when the object is presented to it, it intuits it in a fashion exactly corresponding to the way in which it possesses the object, either within itself or in the imagination.
‘[the intellect] must not judge that external things always are just as they appear to be.’
In all such cases we are liable to go wrong, as we do for example when we take as gospel truth a story which someone has told us;
‘... the the wise man will not judge that whatever comes to him from his imagination ... passes, complete and unaltered, from the external world to his senses, and from his senses to the corporeal imagination’
Rules for the Direction of the Mind, Rule 12
1. On Descartes’ view, do the senses represent things?
2. If so, how is it that the senses never misrepresent things? (Or, if they do sometimes misrepresent, why are they not a source of error)?
3. If not, why must we ‘not judge that external things always are just as they appear to be’?
A resolution?
‘consider the reasons why [vision] sometimes deceives us.
‘those ... who are looking through yellow glass ... attribute this colour to all the bodies they look at’
Optics
Sensory perceptions of tastes,smells, sounds, heat, cold, light, colors and the like ‘do not represent anything located outside our thought’
Principles
Descartes’ big insights
1. The intellect is independent of sensory perceptions: it does not have to accept the principles implicit in perceptual processes.
2. We can explain why perceptual processes implicitly rely on principles which sometimes yield misrepresentations by appeal to the proper purpose of sensory perception.